top of page

How to Read an Xactimate Estimate From Your Insurer: A Homeowner's Line-by-Line Guide

Writer: Austin  Bernaiche
Austin Bernaiche
Nov 12
7 min read

For most homeowners, the first estimate from the insurance company is a long PDF full of codes, abbreviations and columns of numbers. It is also the document that decides how much you are paid. 


Xactimate is everywhere in property claims. According to United Policyholders, insurers and restoration contractors use Xactimate to handle more than half of all property claims in the United States and Canada, and its estimates are only as accurate as the details and pricing entered into them.


This guide walks through how an estimate is organized, how to read a single line item, what the summary page means, how pricing works, and which items are most often left out.


How Is an Xactimate Estimate Organized?

Most insurer estimates follow the same structure, which makes them easier to read once you know where to look:


  • The cover page: your name, the claim number, the date of loss, the type of loss and the adjuster's name. It also identifies the price list used, a code tied to a region and a month.

  • Room-by-room sections: the estimate is grouped by area, such as Kitchen, Living Room or Roof. Each section starts with the room's measurements: wall, ceiling and floor area in square feet, and perimeter in linear feet.

  • Line items: the individual tasks for that room, each on its own numbered line.

  • The summary pages: totals for the whole claim, including replacement cost, depreciation, the deductible and the net payment.

  • Sketches and photos: a floor plan drawn in the software and the adjuster's photos, which are sometimes sent separately. Ask for them if they are missing, because they show what the adjuster measured and saw.


How Do You Read a Line Item?

Each line item is one task, priced and depreciated on its own. The example below shows two common line items for a room with water-damaged walls. The figures are illustrations, not real pricing for any area.

Description

Quantity

Unit price

Tax

RCV

Age/Life

Depreciation

ACV

Remove and replace 1/2 inch drywall, hung, taped, floated, ready for paint

384 SF

$3.10

$28.50

$1,218.90

15/150 yrs

($121.89)

$1,097.01

Seal, prime and paint the walls, two coats

384 SF

$1.20

$9.20

$470.00

8/15 yrs

($250.67)

$219.33

Here is what each column means:


  • Description: the task. "Remove and replace" (often shortened to R&R) means tearing out and installing new material. "Detach and reset" (D&R) means taking something off and putting the same item back, such as a toilet or a light fixture.

  • Quantity and unit: how much of the task, in units such as SF (square feet), LF (linear feet), SY (square yards), SQ (a roofing square, or 100 square feet) and EA (each).

  • Unit price: the price per unit from the regional price list, which bundles materials, labor and equipment for that task.

  • Tax: sales tax on the materials portion.

  • RCV (replacement cost value): the full cost of the task with new materials.

  • Age/Life: the item's estimated age compared with its expected life, which drives depreciation.

  • Depreciation: the reduction for wear and age. Shown in parentheses, it is subtracted from the RCV.

  • ACV (actual cash value): RCV minus depreciation, which is what many policies pay first.


Line items are also grouped by trade, using short category codes such as DRY for drywall, PNT for painting, FCC for carpet, RFG for roofing, WTR for water mitigation, INS for insulation and CLN for cleaning. Seeing a trade missing entirely, such as no INS lines after a ceiling leak, is a quick sign something was left out.


What Does the Summary Page Mean?

The summary page turns hundreds of line items into the numbers that decide your payment. The example below uses illustrative figures.

Summary line

Example amount

What it means

Line item total

$18,400

The total of every line item before tax

Material sales tax

$620

Tax on materials

Overhead and profit

$3,804

A general contractor's overhead and profit, when included

Replacement cost value

$22,824

The full cost to repair with new materials

Less depreciation

($4,150)

The total reduction for age and wear

Actual cash value

$18,674

Replacement cost minus depreciation

Less deductible

($1,000)

Your policy deductible

Net claim

$17,674

The first payment

Recoverable depreciation

$4,150

Often paid later, after repairs are completed

If your policy pays replacement cost, the depreciation held back at first is usually recoverable once the work is done and you submit proof of the cost. The estimate should mark which depreciation is recoverable and which is not. 


If your policy pays only actual cash value, depreciation is generally not paid back. Our guides to water damage claim value and fire damage claim value explain how the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value plays out on real claims.


This is general information about how many estimates and policies are structured, not a coverage opinion on your claim. Your policy's wording controls. For a question about your specific coverage, ask your insurer or the licensed adjuster reviewing your policy.


How Does Xactimate Pricing Work?

Xactimate prices come from price lists published for specific regions and updated over time. Xactware, the company behind Xactimate, explains that price lists differ by area and by month, with general prices updated monthly.


Three pricing details are worth checking on any estimate:


  • The region and month: the price list should match your area and be close to the date the work will be done. An older price list can understate costs when materials and labor have risen.

  • Default pricing versus local reality: United Policyholders notes that if default pricing is not adjusted to reflect the local market, the estimate's output will not be accurate. Local contractor bids are the best evidence of what the work actually costs in your town.

  • Overhead and profit: when a job needs a general contractor to coordinate several trades, such as a kitchen rebuild that involves plumbing, electrical, drywall and flooring, a general contractor's overhead and profit is often added, commonly figured at 10 percent each. An estimate for a multi-trade repair with no overhead and profit is worth questioning.


What Items Are Most Often Missing From an Insurer's Estimate?

An estimate can be priced correctly and still come up short because tasks are missing. These are the items we most often find left out:


  • Finishing the whole surface: painting only the patched section of a wall instead of the full room, which leaves a visible mismatch.

  • Detach and reset work: baseboards, trim, outlet covers, light fixtures, cabinets and appliances that must come off for repairs and go back on.

  • Contents handling: moving furniture out of the way and back, or packing and storing contents during major repairs.

  • Protection and preparation: floor protection, masking and dust containment.

  • Insulation and vapor barrier: behind wet drywall or above a wet ceiling.

  • Debris removal: hauling, dumpsters and disposal fees.

  • Final cleaning: construction cleaning once repairs are finished.

  • Roofing details: waste factor, starter course, ridge cap, drip edge, flashing, steep or high roof charges and, in much of New England, the ice barrier along the eaves that building codes based on the International Residential Code call for. Our guides to wind damage claims and ice dam claims cover roof claims in more depth.

  • Permits and code upgrades: permit fees and work required to meet current code, subject to your policy's ordinance or law coverage.

  • Hidden damage: moisture in subfloors and wall cavities, smoke residue in ductwork, or framing and foundation damage after a vehicle impact.


What Should You Do if the Estimate Seems Too Low?

A low estimate is usually the start of a conversation, not the end of the claim. Insurers routinely revise estimates when they receive better information, often through what is called a supplement.


  1. Get the complete estimate, including the summary pages, the sketch, the photos and the price list identified on the cover page.

  2. Walk the house with the estimate in hand, room by room, and mark anything damaged that does not appear.

  3. Check the measurements against your own. A wrong room size changes every line item in that room.

  4. Get a detailed contractor estimate and compare it line by line, not just by the total.

  5. Ask questions in writing: why an item was excluded, how depreciation was calculated, and whether overhead and profit apply.

  6. Submit missing items with evidence, such as photos, measurements and contractor pricing, and ask for a revised estimate.

  7. Know the options in your policy: Many policies include an appraisal provision for disagreements about the amount of a loss. Your policy sets the requirements for how and when to raise a dispute, so review it or ask your insurer what applies to you.


Frequently Asked Questions About Xactimate Estimates

Why Is My Insurance Estimate Lower Than My Contractor's?

The two are often built differently. A contractor prices the job they will actually perform in your local market, while an insurer's estimate may use default regional pricing, leave out tasks or skip overhead and profit. United Policyholders notes that Xactimate estimates are, in most situations, lower than contractor estimates. Comparing the two line by line shows where the gap comes from.


Can I Ask My Insurer for the Full Xactimate Estimate?

Yes. Ask for the complete estimate, including the summary pages, sketch and photos. Without the line items, there is no way to see what was included or why the total is what it is.


What Does O&P Mean on an Insurance Estimate?

O&P stands for overhead and profit, the general contractor's costs of running the job and a reasonable profit. It is often added when a repair requires several trades to be coordinated.


Will I Get the Depreciation Back?

If your policy pays replacement cost and the depreciation is marked as recoverable, it is usually paid after repairs are completed and you submit proof of the cost. If your policy pays actual cash value only, depreciation is generally not paid back. Your policy sets the conditions that apply.


What Is a Supplement?

A supplement is a request to add items or costs to the original estimate, usually because hidden damage was found once work began or something was missed in the first inspection. Supplements are a normal part of many claims.


Can a Public Adjuster Help Review an Xactimate Estimate?

Yes. A licensed public adjuster represents you, the policyholder, rather than an insurance company. The work is documentation and negotiation: inspecting the damage, reviewing your policy, preparing an independent estimate, and presenting the claim. A public adjuster does not perform repairs.


Because Naiche builds its estimates in Xactimate, the same software your insurer uses, the comparison happens in the same language, line by line. That typically means:


  • Measuring the property with Matterport 3D imaging, so room sizes and quantities are accurate.

  • Building a complete estimate that includes the tasks an insurer's first estimate often leaves out.

  • Checking pricing, depreciation and overhead and profit against your policy and your local market.

  • Submitting supplements with supporting evidence and following up on each disputed item.

  • Keeping you informed, while the decision to accept any settlement stays with you.


See how our process works, or schedule a free consultation to have your estimate reviewed. We represent policyholders, not insurers.

 

Naiche Inc. is led by Austin Bernaiche, a licensed public insurance adjuster in Connecticut, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine, North Carolina, South Carolina, Florida and Utah. Naiche acts only on losses located in those states. This article is general information. It is not legal advice or a coverage opinion, and no particular claim outcome is guaranteed.


 
 
bottom of page