top of page

Car Hit Your House? Whose Insurance Pays, Including When the Driver Is Uninsured

Writer: Austin  Bernaiche
Austin Bernaiche
10 minutes ago
7 min read

A car through the front wall is one of the most jarring things that can happen to a home, and it raises an insurance question most homeowners have never had to think about.


These crashes are more common than they seem. The Storefront Safety Council reports more than 100 vehicle-into-building crashes a day at commercial and public buildings in the United States alone, and homes along busy roads, curves and intersections see their share.


This guide explains who pays in each common scenario, how to choose between the driver's insurance and your own, what happens when the driver has no insurance or too little, what a homeowners policy covers after a vehicle impact, and what to document before the scene is cleared.


Whose Insurance Pays When a Car Hits Your House?

The at-fault driver is responsible, so their auto liability insurance is the policy that ultimately owes for the damage. In practice, your own homeowners policy often pays first, because vehicle damage is a standard covered cause of loss and your insurer has a contract with you, not with the driver. The table below shows how the common scenarios usually play out.

Scenario

Usually paid by

What can change it

Insured driver with enough coverage

The driver's auto liability policy, or your homeowners policy first

Which path you choose; your insurer can recover its payment from the driver's insurer

Insured driver with low limits

The driver's policy up to its limit, then your homeowners policy

The driver's property damage limit and the size of the loss

Uninsured driver

Your homeowners policy

Your deductible; any separate recovery from the driver personally

Hit-and-run driver

Your homeowners policy

A police report helps document the cause

Commercial or delivery vehicle

The business's commercial auto policy, or your homeowners policy first

Commercial policies often carry higher limits than personal ones

You or someone in your household hit the house

Your homeowners policy for the house, your auto policy for the car

Some policies exclude damage to a fence, driveway or walk caused by a household member's vehicle

Sources: Connecticut Insurance Department, Bulletin PC-87; Commonwealth Automobile Reinsurers; standard homeowners policy form HO 00 03 (Maine Bureau of Insurance).


When a government vehicle is involved, such as a town truck or a school bus, special notice rules can apply to claims against a municipality or the state. If that is your situation, speak with an attorney promptly about the steps that apply, while your homeowners claim moves forward on its own track.


Should You Claim Through the Driver's Insurance or Your Own?

You usually have a choice, and each path has trade-offs. Many homeowners open both: a claim with their own insurer to get repairs started, and a report to the driver's insurer so it is on notice.

 

Driver's auto liability insurance

Your homeowners insurance

Your deductible

None

Applies, but your insurer may recover it from the driver's insurer

Who the insurer works for

The driver

You, under your policy

Limit that applies

The driver's property damage limit

Your own dwelling and contents limits

Living expenses while displaced

Possible, but must be proven against the driver

Loss of use coverage under your policy

Speed

Can stall while fault and limits are sorted out

Usually moves faster, since your policy covers the cause of loss

If your insurer pays and then recovers from the driver's insurer, a process called subrogation, any deductible you paid may be returned to you from that recovery. Ask your adjuster to confirm in writing that your deductible will be included in the subrogation demand.


What if the Driver Is Uninsured or Has Too Little Coverage?

This is where your homeowners policy does its most important work. State minimum property damage limits are low compared with the cost of repairing a house:


  • Connecticut: drivers must carry at least $25,000 in property damage liability, according to the Connecticut Insurance Department.

  • Massachusetts: the minimum rose from $5,000 to $30,000 for policies issued or renewed on or after July 1, 2025, according to Commonwealth Automobile Reinsurers. A driver whose policy has not yet renewed under the new rules may still carry the older, lower limit.


A vehicle that breaks through a wall can damage framing, the foundation, utility lines and everything in the room. When the cost passes the driver's limit, your homeowners policy covers the difference under its own terms, minus your deductible. When the driver has no insurance or cannot be found, your homeowners policy is usually the primary source of payment.


Uninsured motorist coverage on an auto policy is generally built around injuries rather than damage to your house, so in most cases it does not replace your homeowners claim.


This is general information about how many policies are written, not a coverage opinion on your claim. Your policy's wording controls. For a question about your specific coverage, ask your insurer or the licensed adjuster reviewing your policy.


What Does Homeowners Insurance Cover After a Vehicle Impact?

A standard homeowners policy lists damage by vehicles as a covered cause of loss. Depending on the impact, a claim can include:


  • The structure: exterior walls, framing, load-bearing elements, the foundation, windows, doors and the roof if the impact shifted it.

  • Utilities: damaged gas, water, sewer and electrical lines, and the inspections and repairs needed to make them safe.

  • Your belongings: furniture and contents damaged by the vehicle or by debris.

  • Emergency work: boarding up openings, temporary shoring to support the structure, and steps to prevent further damage.

  • Engineering: a structural engineer's assessment when the impact may have affected load-bearing elements or the foundation.

  • Code upgrades: work required to bring repaired areas up to current building code, subject to your policy's ordinance or law coverage and its limit.

  • Living elsewhere: if the building official or an engineer says the home is unsafe, your loss of use coverage can pay the extra cost of temporary housing.


The car itself is not covered by your homeowners policy. Damage to the vehicle goes through the driver's own auto coverage.


Why Do Vehicle Impact Claims Get Underpaid?

The visible damage is usually obvious. The underpayment tends to come from what is harder to see.


  1. Structural damage is treated as cosmetic: A wall can look patchable while the framing behind it, the sill plate or the foundation has shifted. Without an engineer's inspection, an estimate may cover drywall and siding but not the structure.

  2. Utility damage is separated or missed: A gas or water line that was bent but not broken can fail later. Insurers may treat utility repairs as a separate matter or limit what they pay for inspections.

  3. Code upgrades are left out: Rebuilding a damaged wall or foundation section in an older New England home often triggers current code requirements that the original construction never met.

  4. The repair scope stops at the impact zone: Matching siding, flooring and finishes beyond the hole the car made can be left out of a first estimate.

  5. Living expenses are disputed: An insurer may question whether the home is truly unlivable. A written notice from the building official or an engineer's report settles that question far better than a description.


What Should You Document After a Car Hits Your House?

The scene is often cleared within hours, so start documenting as soon as everyone is safe.

  1. Call 911 and get the police report number. The report identifies the driver, the vehicle and, in a hit-and-run, the facts of the crash.

  2. Get the driver's name, license plate, insurance company and policy number, and photograph their insurance card if you can.

  3. Photograph and video everything before the vehicle is removed: the car in place, the point of impact, the inside of the room, and every side of the house.

  4. Keep any notice from the building official or fire department declaring the home unsafe or restricting its use.

  5. Record utility company visits, such as a gas shutoff or electrical disconnection, with dates and any paperwork they leave.

  6. Ask for a structural engineer's assessment if the impact reached a corner, a foundation wall or any load-bearing area.

  7. Keep every receipt for board-up work, shoring, hotel stays and meals.

  8. Report the loss to your insurer promptly: Your policy sets the requirements for reporting and documenting a claim, so review it or ask your insurer what applies to you.


Frequently Asked Questions About Vehicle Impact Claims

Will Filing a Homeowners Claim for a Car Crash Raise My Premium?

Rating practices vary by insurer and state, so ask your agent. Keep in mind that a vehicle impact is caused by someone else, and your insurer can pursue the at-fault driver's insurer for what it paid.


Do I Have to Pay My Deductible if Someone Else Hit My House?

If you claim through your homeowners policy, your deductible applies at first. When your insurer recovers from the driver's insurer, your deductible may be repaid from that recovery. If you claim directly against the driver's liability coverage, there is no deductible, but payment depends on the driver's insurer accepting the claim.


What if the Driver's Insurance Company Offers Less Than the Repairs Cost?

The driver's insurer owes up to the driver's property damage limit. If its offer is low, you can open or continue a claim under your homeowners policy for the full cost of repair under your own policy terms, and your insurer can take up the dispute with the driver's insurer.


Is a Car Crashing Into My Business Covered the Same Way?

Commercial property policies generally cover vehicle damage as well, and a business may also have business income coverage for the time it is closed. The same who-pays principles apply, often with a commercial auto policy on the other side.


What if My Own Car Damaged the House?

Your homeowners policy generally covers damage to the house itself, and your auto policy covers your car. Check your policy for limits on damage to a fence, driveway or walk caused by a vehicle owned or driven by someone in your household, which some forms exclude.


Can a Public Adjuster Help With a Vehicle Impact Claim?

Yes. A licensed public adjuster can help with a vehicle impact claim. The work is documentation and negotiation: inspecting the damage, reviewing your policy, preparing a detailed estimate, and presenting the claim. A public adjuster does not perform repairs or structural work. 


On a vehicle impact claim, that typically means:


  • Documenting structural, foundation and utility damage, not just the hole in the wall, with Matterport 3D imaging of the affected areas.

  • Building the estimate in Xactimate, the same estimating software most insurers use, including code-required work where it applies.

  • Coordinating between your homeowners insurer and the driver's insurer when more than one policy is involved.

  • Supporting a loss of use claim when the home is unsafe to live in.

  • Keeping you informed, while the decision to accept any settlement stays with you.


You can bring in a public adjuster before you file or after the claim has started. See how our process works, or schedule a free consultation to talk through your vehicle impact claim. We represent policyholders, not insurers.

 

Naiche Inc. is led by Austin Bernaiche, a licensed public insurance adjuster in Connecticut, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine, North Carolina, South Carolina, Florida and Utah. Naiche acts only on losses located in those states. This article is general information. It is not legal advice or a coverage opinion, and no particular claim outcome is guaranteed.


 
 
bottom of page